Friday, March 10, 2006

Passport Cancelled, UK Citizenship Revoked

So this is how Tom Hanks' character in Terminal felt.

Apologies first off to anybody hoping for a heartrending story about some travesty of justice where a poor traveller is left stranded immobile in a foreign land without a place to call home. The revocation of my UK citizenship and the subsequent cancellation of my passport are in fact very positive things and entirely deliberate on my part. It's one of my worst kept secrets that for the past 18 months I've been applying for Japanese citizenship, and providing proof to the Minister for Justice that I owe allegiance to no other country is the final step in the application process before a decision is made (and from what I gather, the chances of anybody that has survived this far being turned down, are zero). It's just an amazingly ironic coincidence that the day I eventually decided I'd had enough of waiting for my proof of renunciation to turn up (applied for last July), a day spent constantly phoning and faxing the British Embassy, writing to the Home Office, negotiating with the Legal Affairs Bureau, and other important sounding but ultimately stressful stuff, was the exact same day that the piece of paper I'd been chasing eventually turned up (in the late afternoon post, of course). Now I just have to wait a few more months hoping I don't need to leave the country for any reason. It's close, but I can almost taste the banana.

Now I know what a lot of you are thinking – why on earth would somebody such as myself want to give up my British citizenship with all the perks of a European passport, in order to take citizenship in a country like Japan? It certainly wouldn't be the first time I was asked that, but there have in fact been occasions where my reasons were convincing enough to make other people choose to do the same thing. To be honest, I had considered naturalising a number of times but soon dismissed it because I wasn't keen on giving up my European passport, but then one day everything just made sense and I decided it was the thing for me.

First off, it's important to make the distinction between nationality, culture, language, physical appearance and sense of self. Nationality really is the odd one out there, as it probably has the least to say about you as a person. It's a legal status that opens some doors and closes others, and very little more. As somebody that plans to live here permanently, those doors that it opens are very important to me – doors such as the right to come and go without bribing immigration for permission, the right to live here permanently and work freely without requiring a visa, the right to vote, the right to legal protections guaranteed under the constitution that could be (and often are) interpreted to exclude foreign residents, the right to a full paper trail and legal identity which are especially useful when getting married and starting a family – international marriages are not fully recognised here, and the foreign party is legally invisible. The doors it closes – the ability to jump in the short queue at immigration on those odd occasions I go to Britain. Having citizenship also changes the attitudes of people around you. Foreign residents, no matter how long they stay, are always assumed to be guests, and are thus constantly subjected to less than welcoming questions such as "when are you leaving Japan?" and "can you eat Japanese fish?" Being a citizen is really the ultimate nullifying answer to all these questions, and it allows people to open themselves up a little more as it gives you an air of permanence. There are a lot of other minor perks like this too, which I'm sure I'll find out about once I'm accepted.

However, the most important reason to me personally is that I don't want to spend the rest of my life as a half-arsed tourist. If my British citizenship is so important to me, then what am I doing here? The feeling is probably best explained in terms of relationships. A guy and a girl get together, they get on great, so they move in together. They could live that way for the rest of their life, and many choose that option, but the majority then go the extra step of having their relationship publicly and officially legitimised by getting married. This is so much the norm, that not to do so is considered to be some sort of rebellion against the system. Those that have got married will generally confirm that while it hasn't necessarily changed the nature of their relationship, it most certainly is not without meaning. Even questions such as "what if we decide to live separately in the future" don't deter them. Likewise, the way I see it at least, if I'm to spend the rest of my life in a country I wasn't born in, then not taking citizenship when the option is available would seem as unnatural as not marrying somebody I planned to start a family with. I don't often say this, but Permanent Residency Visas are for half-hearted pussies that can't commit. In the blessed words of Jesus Christ himself, so then because thou art lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spue thee out of my mouth.

Sadly though, many disagree on this point, frequently because they're blinded by their own misunderstanding as to the true nature of citizenship. Their loss I guess…

Update I have since been contacted and been informed that the process is complete and I am now a fully fledged Japanese citizen.

13 comments:

  1. I guess you won't be needing the Google ad at the top of tjhe page (for US Citizenship) then! Good on ya mate!

    G

    ReplyDelete
  2. US Citizenship eh? Now there's a thought... Cheers for dropping by!

    ReplyDelete
  3. good for you. One of these days I want to do the same too (become a legal citizen in another country). Have one friend of mine who wishes he was back in Tokyo again.

    ReplyDelete
  4. just came on by from boingboing on account of the subtitled otaku videos. congratulations!

    ReplyDelete
  5. you are not and cannot be Japanese. as you note citizenship is just a few legal rights

    ReplyDelete
  6. My passport says otherwise. What's your point?

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm late to the party, but I have to say that I like the shacking-up vs. marriage analogy. On the flip-side, it's perfectly consistent with why a guy like me who's afraid of commitment would not pursue citizenship (or permanent residency) instead of temporary visas and such. While my citizenship is probably of little value, it's much easier to say that it was not my choice to be born wherever rather than to choose a nationality and stick with it for better or for worse. Also the whole racial discrimination thing, while it sounds like fun to have a legitimate ground to stand on whilst fighting that uphill battle, it's still no small task.

    Anyway, for those who do decide to naturalize (or even marry), as long as you accept the possible downsides, then best of luck to you. A little racial diversity can't hurt in the world's most ethnically homogeneous nation.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, I want to tell you as a dual citizen of both Canadian and Japanese, there is a trick. First, you take your Canadian citizenship and go to UK. Then, you become a dual citizen of UK and Canada, which is easy to get as both of these countries accept dual citizenship. Also, since these two countries are both commonwealth nations, for a Canadian to become British is not difficult, and vice versa. You then when caught with dual citizenship, show proof of renouncing Canadian citizenship and keep the Japanese one. (The Japanese not knowing you are also British take that as settled). You then return to UK and go back to Canada as a British Citizen, and take back your Canadian. Now you got it all back, and Japan thinks you chose Japan at the age of 22.

    ReplyDelete
  9. There's lots more ways to trick the system. If like I was, you were giving up British citizenship, you can just apply for it back once Japanese citizenship is secured, should you be so inclined. It says so in plain English on the renunciation forms. Getting round the technicality isn't the problem. The problem is that Japan doesn't recognise dual citizenship unless you're a second rate dictator of some third world country. If you get caught, your Japanese citizenship would become invalid. Possibly retroactively. This is the best cast scenario. I wouldn't fancy spending the rest of my life looking over my shoulder like that, especially as my profile seems to be getting less and less low of late.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Actually being a dual national is not something you want to tell people especially your employers in Japan. They will often threaten you that they will report you to the government of this fact if you dont do this and that. I also know heard that it is possible for dual citizen japanese women to get coerced into having sex threatening them that they will tell the authorities that they are dual nationals if they don't submit.

    ReplyDelete
  11. That is true. But ex-girlfriends and boyfriends can rat each other out.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Can't wait to become a Japanese citizen and am more than happy to renounce my British citizenship.
    People are constantly telling me I'm stupid blah blah blah but it is my decision and I genuinely believe it is the correct one.
    My family are all Japanese and we are staying here forever.
    My friend, I congratulate (and envy) you!

    ReplyDelete